Ross Hastings and Kieran Antill
Co-Founders, Ne-Lo
Cracker Barrel: When Repositioning Gets Repositioned For You
Make sure you understand the broader environment you're actually doing things in.
Cracker Barrel's rebrand triggered backlash, a presidential comment, and a CEO exit. Was the strategy actually wrong?
This is episode 15 of Making Moves, a weekly mini-podcast where Ne-Lo co-founders Ross Hastings and Kieran Antill pick a company making an interesting strategic move and interrogate it. Unscripted, unedited, under 15 minutes. The Cracker Barrel episode was recorded on 31st July 2026.
This week: Cracker Barrel.
A rebrand that got repositioned for them
Cracker Barrel's rebrand happened roughly a year ago. The backlash was significant, President Trump publicly weighed in, and the CEO has now lost their job over it. What's interesting isn't the design work itself. It's what happened to the story around it.
The brand didn't get to control its own narrative. Removing an old logo character became "going woke" in public conversation, despite there being no actual announcement tying that character to anything problematic. Cracker Barrel's repositioning got repositioned for them, into a culture war story rather than a modernisation story. Without a political figure amplifying that framing, we don't think this backlash reaches anywhere near the same scale.
Traditional isn't automatically a weakness
The core error here wasn't the design decisions themselves. Individually, modernising retail experience, streamlining operations, digitising parts of the customer journey are all reasonable moves. The miss was in reading the climate. In gift giving and food, being traditional is not automatically a liability. Cracker Barrel is one of the few brands with genuine nostalgia built in, and that rebrand read, rightly or wrongly, as an attempt to erase that history rather than modernise its expression.
A crowded pivot, not an open one
Cracker Barrel's actual competitive position is built on place. It sits on highways and freeways, a novelty stop for out of town travellers rather than a regular weekday habit. The ambition behind the original repositioning seems to have been shifting toward becoming a more frequent, everyday choice, something closer to the Uber route regular.
That's not a secret gap in the market. Every category competitor already fights for that lunchtime and weekday dinner repetition business. Cracker Barrel was moving out of a distinctive space into an already dense one, not into open ground. When you're the novelty stop people choose for familiarity, the job is reinforcing that habit, not competing to become someone's regular.
A weak character, not a wrong instinct
We don't think the answer is simply putting the old logo character straight back. He was a fairly two dimensional figure who was never properly activated in the first place. Brands like McDonald's and Burger King have shown that legacy characters can be reworked and given new relevance rather than removed or reinstated unchanged. The better question for Cracker Barrel is what that character actually represents now, and whether he has a real role to play, not whether to reverse the decision wholesale.
There's a genuine opportunity to lean into the nostalgia of the interstate experience while building smaller, more local formats that keep the brand relevant day to day, alongside the traditional hub locations people already associate with road trips.
If this episode raised questions about whether your business needs to reposition, start with What is Repositioning? or take the Repositioning Diagnostic to get a straight answer in four minutes.
Making Moves is a weekly mini-podcast from Ne-Lo, Australia's repositioning consultancy. New episodes every Friday.
Ne-Lo Privacy policy.
Oct 28, 2026
Ne-Lo Group International Pty Ltd (ABN 45 632 746 000) ("Ne-Lo", "we", "us") respects your privacy. This policy explains how we collect, hold, use and disclose personal information, as required by the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth).
Information we collect
We collect contact and professional details (name, email, phone, job title and organisation), event registration and attendance details, the content of enquiries and correspondence, responses to our online tools, information about stakeholders in client projects, and supplier payment details. Our website also collects usage data, such as IP address, browser type and pages visited, through cookies from Framer, HubSpot and Google Analytics.
How we collect and hold it
We collect information directly from you through our website forms, email, events and meetings, and through platforms you use to register with us, such as LinkedIn. We also collect it from our clients and from public sources and business data providers. We hold it in secure, access-controlled cloud systems.
Why we collect, use and disclose it
We use personal information to respond to enquiries, deliver our services, run events, send marketing (you can opt out at any time), manage suppliers and meet our legal obligations. We disclose it to service providers who help us run our business, such as our CRM, website, email and accounting providers, to our consulting partners and clients where needed to deliver work, and where the law requires.
Overseas disclosure
Some of our service providers store information outside Australia, mainly in the United States, the European Union and the United Kingdom.
Access, correction and complaints
To access or correct the personal information we hold about you, or to complain about how we have handled it, email team@ne-lo.com. We will respond within 30 days. If you are not satisfied with our response, you can contact the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner on 1300 363 992.